KNOWLEDGE CENTRE
warning signs
Insurance Claim Delayed? 7 Signs Your Insurer May Be Stalling
Extended silence, repeated document requests, shifting explanations, frequent handler changes — seven patterns that distinguish a stalled claim from one that's just taking time.
Reading time ~ 8 minutes
If your insurance claim is delayed longer than you expected, you're not alone - and you may not be imagining it. Insurance claim delays are one of the most common frustrations policyholders experience during the claims process.
Some delays are a normal part of the claims process. Complex claims genuinely take time, and external dependencies like specialist reports or repair assessments can slow things down through no fault of the insurer.
But some delays are different. Communication becomes vague. Progress stops. The same requests keep appearing. And weeks turn into months without a clear explanation.
Knowing the difference between a claim that is taking time and a claim that has genuinely stalled is the first step to doing something about it.
Here are seven signs worth paying attention to. At a glance - 7 signs your claim may have stalled:
Weeks passing with no updates after providing documents
Repeated requests for information you've already supplied
Vague status updates with no timeline or next step
Frequent changes in claims managers
External reports that never seem to arrive or be finalised
Contradictory explanations from different representatives
Your claim has exceeded typical timeframes with no clear reason
1. Long Periods of Silence After You've Provided Documents
One of the clearest warning signs is extended silence - particularly after you've done everything asked of you.
If you've submitted requested documents and weeks pass without acknowledgement, update, or next step, something has likely stalled internally.
Under the General Insurance Code of Practice and the Life Insurance Code of Practice, insurers are expected to keep policyholders informed of claim progress at regular intervals.
Silence is not neutral - it usually indicates a breakdown in communication that insurers are expected to avoid.
A useful reference point: insurers are generally expected to respond to written correspondence within 10 business days. If that threshold has passed without acknowledgement, a written follow-up is reasonable and warranted.
2. You're Being Asked for Documents You've Already Provided
Receiving a request for information you've already submitted is frustrating - and it happens more often than it should.
Common reasons include:
a change in the claims handler managing your file
documents not being properly recorded in the system
your file being reviewed by multiple internal teams
Occasional duplication can occur in complex claims. But when it happens repeatedly - particularly for the same documents - it may indicate the claim is not being actively managed or that your file is not being properly maintained.
Each time this happens, note it. A pattern of repeated requests is relevant evidence if you need to escalate later.
3. Status Updates That Say Nothing
If the updates you're receiving sound like this
"Your claim is still under review."
"We're waiting on an internal assessment."
"The claim is progressing."
…but no specific timeline, next step, or explanation is provided - the update is not really an update.
Genuine progress updates include the current stage of the claim, what information is still required, and when the next action will occur. Responses that lack this detail may indicate the claim is not currently moving - or that the person responding doesn't have visibility over it.
4. Your Claim Keeps Changing Hands
It is not unusual for an insurance claim to change handlers over a long assessment period. Staff change, teams restructure, and claims are sometimes reassigned.
But when a claim changes hands repeatedly - particularly without clear communication about why - it creates a real problem: each new handler needs time to review the file, understand prior decisions, and confirm documentation. Progress can effectively reset with each transition.
This pattern is worth monitoring closely. When claim handler changes coincide with periods of silence or requests for information already provided, they can compound delays significantly. It also makes it harder to establish accountability for commitments made during earlier stages of the claim.
If your claim has changed hands more than once, ask in writing for confirmation of who is currently responsible for your file and what stage the claim is at.
5. You're Told the Claim Is Waiting on a Report - Indefinitely
Some claims genuinely require specialist input: engineering assessments, medical reports, repair estimates, or investigator findings. These take time, and waiting on them is a legitimate part of the process.
The concern arises when the same explanation - "we're waiting on a report" - is given repeatedly, across multiple contacts, without a timeframe or update on when it will be received.
At that point, it's reasonable to ask:
Which report specifically is outstanding?
Who commissioned it and when?
What is the expected timeframe for receipt?
What happens to the claim once it arrives?
These are factual, reasonable questions. Clear answers indicate the process is moving. Vague ones suggest it may not be.
6. The Explanation Keeps Changing
When you contact your insurer and receive a different explanation each time - one representative says the claim is under assessment, another says additional documents are required, another says it's awaiting approval - that inconsistency is a meaningful signal.
It may indicate that different staff members don't have a clear or shared understanding of where the claim stands. It can also make it difficult for you to know what is actually required to move things forward.
Whatever the cause, inconsistent information creates a practical problem: you cannot act on guidance that contradicts itself.
When this happens, put your questions in writing and ask for a single, clear written response confirming the current status and next steps. Written responses are harder to walk back than verbal ones - and they create a record if the inconsistency needs to be raised formally later.
7. Your Claim Has Been Running for Months Without Clear Progress
Claims vary widely in complexity, and longer timeframes are sometimes genuinely necessary.
But if your claim has been running for several months and you cannot identify what is currently happening, what is still outstanding, or when a decision is expected - that absence of clarity is itself a problem.
Under the relevant Codes of Practice, insurers are expected to provide progress updates- often around every 20 business days even when a claim is genuinely complex. If that standard is not being met, and no clear explanation has been provided, the delay may have moved from reasonable to unreasonable.
For a detailed guide on understanding typical claim timeframes and what the Codes require, read: How Long Does an Insurance Claim Take in Australia? →
Why These Signs Matter
One Sign Isn't a Pattern - But Several Signs Together Are.
It's worth being clear: any one of these signs in isolation may have an innocent explanation. Claims are complex processes involving multiple parties, and not every delay reflects poor handling.
But when several of these signs appear together - particularly silence, repeated document requests, and shifting explanations - they form a pattern that warrants attention and action.
The distinction that matters is this: a claim taking time is normal. A claim where communication has broken down, commitments aren't being met, and explanations keep shifting is something different. You don't need to prove bad faith to be entitled to better service.
What to Do If Several of These Apply to Your Claim
Start by documenting what has actually happened. Write down a timeline of key events - when you lodged, what was requested, what you provided, and what responses you received. This turns a frustrating experience into structured evidence.
Follow up in writing. A calm, factual written request referencing the General Insurance Code of Practice often prompts a more substantive response than a phone call. For a step-by-step guide to getting a response, read: 5 Steps to Get a Response Within 48 Hours →
Know when to escalate. If follow-up doesn't move things, you can lodge a formal complaint through the insurer's Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR) process at any time - there is no mandatory waiting period. If IDR doesn't resolve the issue, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) provides free, independent dispute resolution.
A System Makes the Difference
Recognising the signs is one thing. Having the tools to act on them - calmly, consistently, and with proper documentation - is what actually changes outcomes.
The Insurance Claim Delay Rescue Kit gives you a structured tracking system to log every interaction, a framework for identifying whether your delay is reasonable or not, and a library of AI-powered prompts to help you communicate with your insurer professionally at every stage.
FREE TOOL
Not sure what's happening with your claim?
Claim Pulse is a free 5-minute read on how your claim is being handled. Answer eight questions and get a clear picture of the patterns in your responses - what they usually indicate and one step that creates immediate clarity.